Engaging in discussions with individuals deeply committed to certain theological perspectives can be challenging, particularly when those perspectives diverge from mainstream Christian doctrine. I recently shared a video on this topic, inviting followers of Shepherd's Chapel to substantiate their beliefs with clear biblical evidence. My focus was on their teaching that the "elect" were chosen due to actions in a supposed "first earth age," where they were justified by standing with God against Satan. This concept lacks explicit support in Scripture and warrants careful examination.
The Bible, particularly in passages like Romans 8–9 and Ephesians 1–2, teaches that the elect are believers in Christ, chosen by God's grace, not by any works or actions—whether in this life or a hypothetical prior age. Romans 9:16 emphasizes that God's choice "does not depend on human desire or effort, but on God’s mercy." Similarly, Ephesians 2:8–10 and 2 Timothy 1:9 affirm that salvation and justification come through faith, not performance. These passages present a unified message: our standing before God is rooted in His grace, not our deeds.
Having studied Shepherd's Chapel's teachings for many years, I once held these views myself. However, I came to see them as inconsistent with biblical truth. In my video's and blog comment section, some suggested I was affiliated with the Christian Apologetics and Research Ministry (CARM). To clarify, I have no formal connection with CARM, though I appreciate their efforts to address theological errors in various groups, including Shepherd's Chapel, Mormonism, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and others. My perspective comes from personal study and reflection, not an organizational agenda.
Shepherd's Chapel's teaching that election and justification stem from actions in a "first earth age" raises significant concerns. This doctrine suggests a works-based salvation, which contrasts sharply with the gospel of grace articulated in Scripture. The idea of a pre-existent earth age where individuals earned their status as elect is not explicitly supported in the Bible and risks undermining the sufficiency of Christ’s work on the cross.
Engaging with Shepherd's Chapel adherents can be difficult, as discussions sometimes lead to defensiveness or personal attacks rather than constructive dialogue. My hope is to encourage open, respectful conversations grounded in Scripture, where we can explore these teachings together and seek clarity.
I am grateful for the journey that led me to reconsider these beliefs and embrace a biblically grounded understanding of salvation. My prayer is that others will also seek truth through careful study of God’s Word.
Soli Deo Gloria!